Hagerty, Inc. (HGTY) Stock

Understand Hagerty, Inc.: how it makes money

Hagerty insures classic, collector, and exotic vehicles and boats, earning underwriting profit and commission fees from a community of 920,000 enthusiast members. The core insurance book dominates revenue, while a growing marketplace and media layer deepens loyalty and lowers customer acquisition costs.

Profit comes from underwriting a specialty collector-vehicle book at a roughly 90% combined ratio, then re-capturing a portion through Hagerty Re, all fed by a 920,000-member community that locks in 89% policy retention and keeps acquisition costs low.

Business quality (Weak): A structurally attractive niche insurer with a powerful community moat and a 90% combined ratio, but trading at a multiple that leaves very little room for the thin near-term GAAP profitability (operating margin around 1%).

Valuation: At 67× earnings, HGTY trades 410% above the Insurance average (13×).

Bull case

• Raised EBITDA guidance signals leverage: Management raised 2026 adjusted EBITDA guidance to $270-$280 million, indicating the cost base is scaling well below the premium growth being added through the State Farm conversion and organic write.
• State Farm pipeline is multi-year: The conversion of 525,000 State Farm-collected policies remains on pace to run through 2028, providing a known and staggered revenue ramp that is largely insulated from new-customer acquisition costs.
• Reinsurance layer underwrites profitably: Hagerty Re posted an 88% first-half combined ratio and a 41% loss ratio, confirming that the re-captivation model layers meaningful underwriting profit on top of the same collector-car risk.

Bear case

• Valuation prices in perfection: At a P/E of 66.6x versus the insurance industry average of 13.1x (410% above the sector), the stock embeds sustained premium growth and margin expansion that has not yet showed up in GAAP results.
• Core retention ticked lower: Core-book retention declined modestly year over year and sequentially, which threatens the low-acquisition-cost flywheel; even a 1-2 point erosion would raise the blended cost to serve and compress underwriting economics.
• H2 EPS step-down from expenses: Acquisition-expense benefits fall to $15 million in the second half and to zero in the fourth quarter, so reported earnings will step down sharply even if revenue stays flat, complicating the multiple story for growth-oriented holders.

Hagerty, Inc. earnings call transcripts

• HGTY Q4 FY25 earnings call transcript (reported 2026-02-26) · analysis
• HGTY Q2 FY25 earnings call transcript (reported 2025-08-04) · analysis

All HGTY earnings calls

Related Companies (Insurance; 8 comparable insurers)

• Enact Holdings, Inc. (ACT)
• CRAWFORD & CO (CRD)
• RLI Corp. (RLI)
• Skyward Specialty Insurance Group, Inc. (SKWD)
• Root, Inc. (ROOT)
• United Fire Group, Inc. (UFCS)
• Universal Insurance Holdings, Inc. (UVE)
• Safety Insurance Group, Inc. (SAFT)